WEEKLY ROUND -UP
Each Week We Answer 100s of Legal Questions. These are some of the questions.
Week Of June 3, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "How do I get current month-to-month tenants out of a home that I just purchased? The sales agent told me that they had a lease when I bought the property, but now I have learned the hard way. There is no written lease. It is middle of the month and they still are not out of the home as they promised they would be."
A: Based on your facts, as month-to-month tenants, they need to be evicted using a 30 days notice. Since they say they will be out by the middle of the month and they are still in the home, you will need to wait at least 30 days before you file the complaint with the court. For what it is worth, never purchase a home that allow tenants to remain in it after closing on the home, without first seeing a valid written lease and a rent roll – or payment history. Don’t close on a home without this. Also, make sure that you get an assignment of the leases when you do purchase a home with the home seller intending to sell with the tenants to remain.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Can I fight a lien? I have a contractor who did a very poor remodeling job on my home. I am happy to pay them for the materials but NOT the work. Does writing "paid in full" protect me? What about not getting any notice that a lien is being put on a property before it actually happens?"
A: One would have to see any documentation related to this matter. But there are laws that regulate when liens for work performed can be placed upon your property. For instance, only a licensed contractor can file a lien on property that they have provided work and materials., and they are limited to up to 90 days from the furnishing of the work to file the lien. Additionally, this matter from your fact pattern seems that it can be negotiated. Definitely provide documents.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Will I be held responsible for a foreclosure property that was purchased before I got married? I am on the deed, not on the mortgage."
A: No. If you did not sign on the promissory note, you are not personally obligated o the bank for payment. However, the default may still be reflected on your credit report since you are signed as a mortgagor on the mortgage.
Week Of May 20, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "Can the homeowner of the house that I live in, change the locks without notifying me?"
A: If the landlord’s intent is to put you out of the home, then It is illegal for a landlord to change the locks. They may be subject to penalties by the court. An illegal lock-out does not have to just be by changing the locks, it can also occur when the landlord shuts off utilities. Contact an attorney.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I have had a large billboard sign on a corner advertising my business for over 50 years. For at least 30 years, I have had permits from the state to use this billboard. Do I have a prescriptive easement?"
A: One of the key elements to your fact pattern that suggest you do not have an easement by prescription is that you have been issued “sign permits by the state for over 30 years.” If this was an individual, ‘granting permission’ defeats claims of adverse possession or claims of easements by prescription. Also, this being a government entity makes your assertions almost impossible. An experienced real estate attorney should review your documents / surveys / permits etc.
QUESTION NO. 3: "What do you do when you're getting sued for credit card debt? What's the next step to take?"
A: In general, if you feel you don’t owe the amount, then you will need to file a written objection within 30 days from the day you were notified by the creditor. There are federal laws that protect people against debt collectors / attorneys. If they do not respond to your letter or continue to insist that you owe them the money, then it is best to consult with an attorney. If you do owe the amount, but can’t pay the balance, perhaps you can save the money on an attorney, and negotiate a new balance and payment on that balance with the creditor.
QUESTION NO. 4: "Over the past 16 months, I fought hard for an investment property that another party claimed that they owned. Well, the judge disagreed with them and awarded me the property. The court gave me a judgment. It’s signed and everything, but now the title agent says that the other party still shows up on MY title. I gave them the judgment, but the title agent said I didn’t do enough and that they cannot use this judgment as a way to clear the title for my closing. What do I do as this is soooo frustrating?"
A: From your facts, it seems that while you may have received the judgment, you still have to take several more steps for the title company to accept it for their records. I am surprised that they did not help you with this further. Nonetheless, you will first have to get the court order certified. Just call the court clerk and they will issue a certified judgment for a nominal fee. Second, once you recieve the certified judgment, you will need to record it with the Registrar of Deeds for your county. This order then will show on your public property record – the title company will recognize this filing and honor the judgment. A quick note, you can also save valuable time and bring the certified court order to the title company for their office to record. This way you don’t have to wait for the county to process the filing.
Week Of May 13, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "Is a handwritten purchase agreement, signed and dated by both parties, enforceable in Michigan? I have a lease with an Option to Purchase. However, the seller got a better offer and is now treating my option as a lease only, using every available means to cancel my agreement and by having me evicted"?
A: A contract must have an Offer, Acceptance, Consideration, Mutuality of Obligation, Competency and Capacity. An Option to Purchase is a contract unto itself provided the above “elements of a contract” have been met. But options do expire. The Seller may be able to sell the property to someone else if the Option is no longer valid. You should allow an attorney to review the Option to determine its validity.
QUESTION NO. 2: "If your landlord lets someone other than the tenant store items in your business location, is that a breach of your lease"?
A: What do the lease provisions say? Lease provisions will prevail and if there are no terms that allow for such action, it may be a breach. The question is how have you been damaged? If you have evidence of damage or that you can’t store your own items on your leased property, and provide evidence that the third party items were stored in your leased space, then you may have a basis for an action. Contact an attorney to review the lease.
QUESTION NO. 3: "What can I do if I have a default judgment against me? I wasn't even aware of the fact that I was even sued and the allegations against me are not even valid."
A: When you have a default judgment that needs to be set aside, you have to file your motion to set this aside within a very short time frame. Usually up to a year from the date that the judgment was entered. Also, you will have to have had a valid defense against the allegations. You will have to have an attorney argue before the court that issued the judgment that you did not get served the lawsuit and that you had a ‘meritorious” defense.
QUESTION NO. 4: "My mother & I are both on a mortgage. She's the principal borrower. She passed 3 months ago. My mother left no will. Can I assume the mortgage? My sister says she is entitled to half of the home's value and now wants me to sell it. I have lived here for over 17 years. She says she can force me to sell the home and it doesn't matter that I paid half the mortgage payment when my Mom was alive. Now my sister's attorney just sent me a threatening letter. What rights do I have"?
A: To start, we would need to see how you hold title to the property. Was it held jointly? If it is just you and your sister, and your mother left no will, the home will still need go through probate. If your mother passed without a will and you did not hold title jointly with your mother. then the probate court may order the home sold in order to satisfy your sister’s interest in your mother’s estate. You may have the ability to purchase your mother’s half Interest in the home, but only the probate court can determine the amount needed after a valuation of the property and all other creditor claims against your mother’s estate are addressed and satisfied. So many issues that are left to be sorted out because your mother failed to have a will or a proper estate plan in place. This is why having an estate plan, is so important.
Week Of May 6, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "My landlord doesn't have a Certificate of Occupancy and he is not having any of the maintenance done to the house. They say that the lease controls repairs - not the city. What can I do"?
A: Most municipalities require that landlords register their rental properties with the city building department. Homes for rent must have occupancy permits. If the city requires registration and inspection, these regulations will prevail over any lease terms that you have with the landlord. The landlord will have to make the repairs regardless of what the lease says. Check with your city’s building department. Understand that if the home does not meet code you may be required to move as well. Another consideration is that if the property is not “habitable” you can notify your landlord that you are depositing rent into a bank escrow account for the landlord’’s benefit, and monies will be released upon repair. Document your communication with the landlord in writing.
QUESTION NO. 2: "The city wants my old barn demolished or fixed up? What are my rights against the city and can it be stopped"?
A: Generally, municipalities have the right to enforce building and zoning ordinances that do not comply with safety, fire or blight codes. While the property may not be open to the public, there are a host of other reasons the government can issue a citation. A real estate attorney would need to review your city’s zoning code.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a prospective landlord ask to "inspect" my current residence before renting to me in Michigan"?
A: I am aware of landlords that drive by a tenant’s current home to inspect the upkeep when making a decision to lease. You do not have to comply with this request, but then there is nothing illegal about the landlord refusing to rent to you provided that it is not based on any protected class under federal law and fair housing laws. (Race, sex, sexual orientation, religion, or marital status.)
Week Of April 29, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "How do I get a judgment put on someone's credit report"?
A: You have to be a subscriber to the various credit bureaus to report judgments and collection matters. It should be noted that certain credit agencies do send ‘researchers’ to the courts to pull this information. It is up to the agencies to then decide if they place on reports. I am aware of one bureau that will no longer report judgements.
QUESTION NO. 2: "How do I acquire property where the owner is unknown and it has been vacant for at least 10 years or more"?
A: Please know that in Michigan an action for adverse possession requires 15 years. To prevail there must be actual, visible, open, notorious, exclusive, hostile, continuous, and uninterrupted use of the property by the person filing for the right to possess the property. Just because the property is “abandoned,” someone must be paying property taxes to keep it from tax foreclosure. My suggestion is that you go to the property tax department and see whose name is on the tax bill, then write to them that you have an interest in their property. Remember, only licensed attorneys can dispense legal advice. Court clerks, real estate agents, accountants, etc must be a licensed lawyer to provide legal advice.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I purchased a house in Michigan and sold it to a couple on lease to own. They have now paid off the loan. How do I transfer the deed to them"?
A: You would convey your property interest by a deed. What type of deed will depend on the agreement that the two parties made. Did you agree to transfer with a quit claim deed, a covenant deed or a warranty deed? Which one you select affects your legal rights.
Week Of April 22, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "Can I purchase the redemption rights for $1000 from the owner of the property if the sheriff's sale happened last week?"
A: Yes. The homeowner can alienate or sell their redemption rights. However, the Michigan Court of Appeals recently held in a case that the mortgagor may, after the original mortgage transaction, sell or convey his or her equity of redemption to the mortgagee by a separate and distinct contract entered into for good faith and for valid consideration, but “the exchange must be fair, frank, honest, and without fraud, misconduct, undue influence, oppression or unconscionable advantage of the poverty, distress or fears of the mortgagor.” This means that you must have the proper conveyance and releases. Otherwise, you open yourself up to a lawsuit.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My mom is elderly and wants my name on the deed to her house that is paid for. Do we need to hire a lawyer for this?"
A: What kind of deed? A quit claim deed? A Warranty Deed? A Covenant Deed? A Ladybird Deed? Does she want you to hold it Jointly with Rights of Full Survivorship or as tenants in common? If you don’t draft deeds on a regular basis, it is probably best to use a real estate attorney to properly convey title to a property. That way you know it is done right and there are no far reaching legal or tax consequences.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I have been fixing and renting houses for over 15 years. I am being told by the city building department that I have to hire licensed contractors to do work on my rental(s) because I am not licensed. Why should I have to pay an electrician when I am capable of doing the work myself. I pay the City an inspection fee anyways. Is their statement true?"
A: The city has to ensure that your rental property is up to building code and it is common for investors to pay an annual fee for a rental inspection. If you are doing work that requires a permit, the permit can be pulled in your name or in your licensed contractor’s name. Whoever pulls the permit is responsible for the quality of work. If it passes code, then there should be no further questions.
Week Of April 15, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "My home was sold in foreclosure in 2020. I received a letter regarding the release of mortgage account paid in full only to find out I had a deficiency on the balance. Should I still have a deficiency?"
A: The discharge, if done in error, does not change the status of your loan deficiency. However, the mortgage lender would need to file a notice with the Registrar of Deeds that the discharge was not effective.
QUESTION NO. 2: "We have a survey dispute with the neighbors. They are now selling the house, should we contact their realtor?"
A: No. You could be seen as interfering with a third party’s transaction. The Michigan Seller Disclosure Act requires your neighbor to disclose to potential buyers if there is a boundary issue. Additionally, until a court order clarifies the boundary, it is nothing more than a dispute with no basis and with no legal determination.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a person on SSI disability own property, when SSI limits the amount of cash that they can have ($2,000.00) in the bank?"
A: Generally speaking a person who collects disability can own real estate. If you are speaking in terms of financing a property with a mortgage, then your disability income should be included in the income calculations, provided the disability is not temporary. So for financing purposes, disability income may not help you qualify to refinance or purchase a home.
Week Of April 8, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "The advertisement for the property said the lot was 426' x 215', but would be redrawn to 500' x 250'. After the purchase order was signed, the lines were surveyed at 395' x 220'. What now?"
A: So the legal description / lot size was misrepresented in the home listing. Unless you made the listing document itself as part of the purchase agreement, it cannot be relied upon and the seller is not liable to you for the stated lot size. You did your due diligence by having the property surveyed. There should be a contingency period in which you can either move forward or cancel the transaction. You should also have your earnest money returned or if you determine if the price is appropriate for the lot size, you have the option to move forward.
QUESTION NO. 2: "In a house closing, are all credits and debits to the buyer and seller required to be written in closing paperwork? The loan officer emailed my wife saying that he is waiving the tax service fee. I called the loan officer and asked him to put it in a formal document and sign it. He refused saying the email was good enough."
A: First, a tax service is usually charged by the loan servicing company which is often a third party fee. It does need to be disclosed on the Good Faith Estimate. If this fee changes, the Good Faith Estimate must be re-disclosed. Based upon your narrative, the email is evidence in writing that he is ‘waiving’ the fee. However, he may not have the authority to approve said ‘waiver.’ Contact his manager and if it escalates, contact the state. Loan officers and mortgage companies are regulated by state and federal laws.
QUESTION NO. 3: "My mother, father and I are on a quit claim deed with survivorship. My mom passed and my dad remarried. Do I still have the rights to the deed?"
A: Generally, a recorded quit claim deed will prevail provided that the grantor language (right of survivorship) is expressed properly.
Week Of April 1, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "What type of deed must I file when I sell my interest in a land contract? My buyer says that I promised them a warranty deed, but I explicitly wrote in the contract that I would provide a quit claim deed. Now, the title agent insists that I provide a warranty deed or they will not insure the buyer's title."
A: There are several types of deeds that you could provide. This is based upon your contract provisions, and there is no required deed type per se. A quit claim deed is most preferred from a seller’s perspective, however, your buyer will most likely want a warranty deed. So your title agent is basically “killing your deal” if they are insisting on a warranty deed when you have contracted only for a quit claim deed.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I have been married for 10 years and own a house with my husband. We are now getting divorced. I do not want the house and he wants to refinance on his own and assume the mortgage. Will I get anything from the refinance?"
A: If there is a divorce decree, then the provisions of the divorce decree control how the proceeds of a refinance are issued. If the judgment has not yet been issued, then you will need to work out the amount of proceeds you are expecting from the refinance with your spouse, or it will most likely be negotiated between the attorneys.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I bought a new construction home last December. I've had nothing but problems. Is there a lemon law for homes?"
A: There are contract laws and building codes that pertain to new home construction. Hopefully your home was built by a licensed Michigan builder. That is where you need to start. Then have a real estate attorney review the provisions of your builder’s agreement. You will need to support your allegations with evidence of poor workmanship: third party estimates, photos etc.
QUESTION NO. 4: "I signed a land contract with a company. Two years later the company owner/manager directed me to make payments to his personal account and texted me his personal account number. I have made two payments to his account. Is this even legal? Am I doing something that can be a problem later?"
A: If the agreement is with the company, and payment specifies payment to the company, then the payment shouldn’t go elsewhere. If the LLC is a single member LLC, there may be an argument for the payment to go to their personal account and in this case, it is not fraud. Keep track of your payments – you should have an attorney review the land contract document.
Week Of March 25, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "Would you please tell me whether or not I have to accept an offer of the full asking price I received on my property? I feel that the realtor has been pressuring me to accept it."
A: Just because you receive a full list price offer does NOT necessarily mean you have to accept the offer. What are the other terms – there are variables that have nothing to do with price that may not make it a good offer – for example, what are financing terms, types, inspection and closing contingencies, etc. Too many to name. So 24 hours to review an offer when you want an attorney to review – is not acceptable – you should never feel rushed.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I am a landlord evicting a tenant. I am in the process of selling my home. Can I still go after my tenant after I sell the home, for past rent due to me?"
A: Generally speaking, you can sell the home, but then if you are NO longer the owner / landlord you will no longer have standing in court to bring your action for money damages or possession unless your new buyer assigns that right or leaves that right to you after closing.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I want to determine if it is worth bringing a law suit against a bad actor - should I first do an asset search on the potential defendant before proceeding with my attorney?"
A: While there is nothing wrong with having your attorney do an asset search, the results you seek are not indicative of future collectability. Judgements are good for 7 to 10 years so people with hidden or no assets can have their assets attached at a later date. Likewise people and companies with assets can and do file bankruptcy on judgements. No attorney can predict future collectability of a defendant, so overly rely on an asset search – which is nothing more than a snapshot of a person or company’s assets at any given time.
QUESTION NO. 4: "Can a commercial property owner kick a tenant out for subleasing a property to another party? There is a part of the building lease that says I can sublease?"
A: We would need to see the provision, but it is common in the industry for such provisions to require written approval from the landlord before the sublease can move forward. Check the provision again to ensure that this is not the case.
Week Of March 18, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I am buying a condo. I have signed all documents including the Purchase Agreement. Next step Closing. Can I withdraw without losing my deposit at this point?" I used an AI generated documnent and I don't see where it allows me to get my deposit back if something falls through.
A: A real estate attorney needs to review the sales agreement to see what provisions apply and if there are any penalties, or legal remedies available to the seller. Artificial Intelligence (A.I.) may be the “next big thing” but it simply does not have the ‘experience” to cover all the bases for you, the client. A.I. content pulls information from across the internet, but there are numerous contract provisions that may or may not be appropriate for your circumstances; an attorney should create the document that will protect your specific interests.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Can an associate broker operate a property management business aside from the company he is licensed with?"
A: In Michigan, the state requires that a property management company be owned and operated by at least one person who is licensed as a real estate broker. To the extent that you can operate such a company and also be licensed with your current broker is a determination that can be made between the two parties.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a building inspector enter into a private home without a warrant?"
A: Municipalities have wide latitude to enact building codes and enforce them for the benefit of public safety. If the home is condemned or has other immediate safety issues, the city should have tagged the property and also sent letters to the owners, based upon the owners’ registered address, notifying the owners of the problems. If this property you speak of is a public safety hazard and they are not getting any responses from the owner, I believe the city has the right to enter the property to inspect and secure the property. Furthermore, I am assuming this property is located in Michigan and therefore, Michigan law will apply.
QUESTION NO. 4: "Our real estate broker is charging a base fee of $500 and this was not disclosed verbally or in writing. When we questioned the broker about it, he said the office charges a minimum $500 per house for administrative costs. Is this normal?"
A: Administrative fees are often disclosed in the listing agreement. Also, sometimes the property listing agreement will say the fee is “x amount, but never less than $X.” But whatever the charge, it must be disclosed in writing or it cannot be assessed or collected by the broker.
Week Of March 11, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I bought a house without an inspection and found out that the seller closed off some basement rooms to hide mold and structural issues as well. What are my rights?"
A: Just because you forgo a home inspection when you purchased your home does not necessarily mean that you are stuck with a property’s defective condition. However, it may be more difficult to make claims against a seller in these circumstances. Therefore, unless you were relying upon a seller’s completed disclosure statement that says the home is structurally sound, you may have taken the property in its current state without further recourse against the seller. Seek further counsel.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Recently an investor gave me a cash deposit to purchase my property. No written contract was signed and no receipt was given. A month later he called me to cancel the deal. Do I have to give the money back?"
A: Without a written purchase agreement, you do not have a valid contact. Real estate transactions, especially those dealing with purchases, need to be in writing pursuant to the Statute of Frauds. My suggestion is that you return the deposit. Based upon your facts, you haven’t even detailed the terms of how the deposit was to be treated. Questions remain as to when the deposit was to be credited to your proposed buyer or what bank or title company was holding the deposit. What other contingencies affect the deposit? Without written detail this ‘transaction’ is difficult to enforce. Hence, the need for a written document with specific provisions to guide the parties to a closing.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I just paid off my home and the mortgage was with a private lender (person). What documents should I expect from them and what should I get recorded with the county?"
A: After a homeowner pays off a mortgage in full, they need to obtain a mortgage discharge from their lender. The lender needs to provide the discharge to the mortgagee within 60 days of the receipt of the loan payoff. Additionally, most mortgage contracts call for the lender to record the discharge with the county registrar of deeds. In a private mortgage arrangement, it is best for the homeowner to record the mortgage discharge. If the loan involves a land contract, then land contract buyers do not receive a discharge. Instead, they receive a deed from the seller. The deed serves as proof that the terms of the land contract were met, and the buyer is now on title to the property as the owner.
QUESTION NO. 4: "I had a fire at my building. The company I bought it from through a land contract, still shows as the insured. Do I have a right to the insurance proceeds even if I am not named on the fire policy? The seller says I am not entitled to the insurance proceeds."
A: The insurance company will pay the claim to whoever is listed as a “loss payee” on the policy. How insurance proceeds will be handled thereafter will be controlled by the land contract provisions. This is an important clause that should be in every real estate contract. So if your seller is named on the policy, and you are not, your attorney would have to review the contract to make the claim for proceeds against the seller. Just a word of note, nothing stops you from being listed as a proposed insured on a property casualty agreement since it sounds as if you have an ‘insurable interest.’
Week Of March 4, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I am buying a condo. I have signed all documents including the Purchase Agreement. Next step is the Closing. But now I don't want to move from my current home. I have so many memories here. My family and frieends are close by. I have changed my mind. Can I withdraw without losing my deposit at this point?"
A: A real estate attorney needs to review the sales agreement to see what provisions apply and if there are any penalties, or legal remedies available to the seller. By the way, we understand your reluctance to move, but make sure it is what you really want to do, because backing out of a deal can be costly.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Can an associate broker operate a property management business aside from the company he is licensed with?"
A: In Michigan, the state requires that a property management company be owned and operated by at least one person who is licensed as a real estate broker. To the extent that you can operate such a company and also be licensed with your current broker is a determination that can be made between the two parties.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a building inspector enter into a private home without a warrant?"
A: Municipalities have wide latitude to enact building codes and enforce them for the benefit of public safety. If the home is condemned or has other immediate safety issues, the city should have tagged the property and also sent letters to the owners, based upon the owners’ registered address, notifying the owners of the problems. If this property you speak of is a public safety hazard and they are not getting any responses from the owner, I believe the city has the right to enter the property to inspect and secure the property. Furthermore, I am assuming this property is located in Michigan and therefore, Michigan law will apply.
Week Of Feb 25, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I found severe structural damage to a garage floor during the final walkthrough that the inspector didn't catch because the garage entrance was blocked during the scheduled inspection. Do I still have to close on this house?"
A: If there is a structural issue or home defect that comes to light prior to a closing and the seller should have disclosed the defect that was known to them, then you may have grounds to cancel the transaction. The fact the home inspector could not get into the garage to do their home inspection is important to note. I would suggest that you speak with a real estate attorney further so that they can review your documents, before an anticipated closing. As far as commission driven sales people, they are not attorneys and cannot provide legal advice.
QUESTION NO. 2: "What if my land contract buyer keeps ignoring the payment terms — they pay, but not the right amount. We are almost done with the contract after five years. I don't want to take them to court. What is my option otherwise?"
A: You can keep taking the payments, but let them know that you are not waiving any of your rights. Since the contract is almost paid off, when you generate your payoff, make sure you add any late fees to the final payoff before you provide them with the deed.
QUESTION NO. 3: "In Michigan, what happens when parties to a contract allege that the other party breached the contract terms? The building's seller is pulling out of our deal, alleging that I did not inspect the property in time, but they were the ones who had large metal crates that obstructed the inspection."
A: To establish a breach of contract, one must prove “(1) there was a contract, (2) the other party breached the contract, and (3) the breach resulted in damages to the party claiming breach.” Bank of America, NA v First American Title Ins Co, 499 Mich 74, 100; 878 NW2d 816 (2016). The salient element is the second, when both parties alleging that the other breached the contract. “The rule in Michigan is that one who first breaches a contract cannot maintain an action against the other contracting party for his subsequent breach of failure to perform.” Michaels v Amway Corp, 206 Mich App 644, 650; 522 NW2d 703 (1994). “However, that rule only applies when the initial breach is substantial.” Id (emphasis added). “In determining whether a breach is material, the court should consider whether the non-breaching party obtained the benefit it reasonably expected to receive.” Omnicom of Mich v Giannetti Inv. Co, 221 Mich App 341, 348; 561 NW2d 138 (1997).
Week Of Feb 18, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "How can I stop my sister from using a power of attorney for my father who happened to pass away last month? She was going to rent out of my father’s rental homes to a third party, but now, I need a place to live. I intend to move into this home."
A: A power of attorney expires upon the death of the party who grants their power of attorney (the “Principal”). So your sister, (the “attorney in fact”) cannot enter into any binding transactions after the death of the principal. What happens with your father’s rental home will have to be determined by his will, if he left one.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My land contract buyer has not been paying. For many reasons, we thought he abandoned the house. We went to the house, opened the door and found that his stuff was still there. We changed the locks but left a new key. Can he sue us for breaking and entering?"
A: You are the owner of the home. Provided that the facts are reasonable for someone to believe that the person had abandoned the property, then by law you have the right to secure the property. If you INTENTIONALLY changed the locks, knowing that the buyer / tenant was still in the home, then you have a BIG problem. It is called Lock-out and the penalties for Lock-out are very expensive. If you went to the home to secure it, reasonably believing that he had left, provided that you changed the locks and gave him a new key, then it will help to show that your conduct was not malicious. HOWEVER, there are two sides to this story, and while you are the owner of the home, you can still be sued this is a civil matter.
Click Here For More Information On This Topic |
QUESTION NO. 3: "In the disclosure, the seller said a hot tub would not stay. We did not want them to leave the hot tube because it was GROSS - in bad shape -Well, they left the hot tub behind (Thanks but No thanks!) and now it is going to cost us $1100 for it to be removed. We want them to pay for it. Who is right?"
A: A purchase agreement is a legally binding contract. Generally speaking, if the seller represents in the purchase agreement that they will remove the hot tub from the home upon the sale, then they need to take it with them either before or after the closing occurs.
Week Of Feb 11, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I was told by my real estate agent that I can force my family member to sell a home that we own together. Is true or even possible that in a partition action (my brother and I are fighting over my late mother’s home) that a judge could force the sale of a house regardless of whether we consented to the sale? What if we own the property jointly? What if I want to buy out my brother’s interest?"
A: In a partition action, you could elect to pay off your brother’s interest if he fails to work with you. Nothing prevents you from paying off his 1/2 of the fair market value of the property. This would be offset by all of your contributions made to the home over these past years, including payment of taxes, repairs etc. real estate / probate attorney. Also, you need to know that if the property is held jointly, the court does not have such discretion to order the sale of a home. So you need to verify how title is held.
QUESTION NO. 2: "The seller is not cooperating with a payoff on a land contract to sell the home I purchased. I paid on a land contract for years and the seller will not give me the deed. What now?"
A: You should always have the seller execute the deed at the time the land contract is signed and submit the deed to an attorney’s escrow for when the land contract is paid off; the agreement is satisfied. This way you don’t have to chase after the seller at a later date.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I have an offer on my house that is less than the asking price. However, they also want me to pay seller concessions. Is it normal to ask the seller to pay the buyer's closing cost in addition to paying their own closing costs?"
A: Yes, this is common in a less than “robust” seller’s market. These days, seller concessions are not as common because the real estate market is very good. However, often the real estate agent will increase the asking price to accommodate for “seller concessions,” which usually is no more than 3% of the purchase price.
Week Of Feb 4, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I want to sell half interest in my home to my son. He will be occupying the premises. I want to understand joint ownership with the right of survivorship. I am 75 years old and in good health. My goal is to avoid probate. Can this be done?"
A: The answer will depend upon several variables, but generally, owning a property jointly (with specific legal language) will allow your son to take title to the property upon your death. There are several types of deeds that will help accomplish your concerns without going through probate. You should definitely speak with a real estate / probate attorney.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Before my father died, he deeded our family home to his living trust. The problem is that there is no living trust because he never signed it. The title company will not allow the house to close now. What do I do?"
A: Because there is no effective and valid trust in existence, there is no where for the property to be conveyed to. Since there is an ineffective transfer, the property remains in your father’s estate. Therefore, there needs to be an estate opened with the probate court. Only then can the home be conveyed by an assigned personal representative of the estate to your buyer.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I’m currently getting ready to pay off my long-term land contract (20 years). Is there a way to avoid getting my taxes reassessed?"
A: You should contact your City Assessor’s office to let them know that you will have legal title. You may have been given the principal residence tax exemption earlier on. So check with them. I would recommend that you contact the office to discuss further if you have any other questions.
Week Of Jan 21, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "I’d like to keep the house I bought with girlfriend but she will not let me buy her out nor will she agree to sell. She is 50/50 on deed in Michigan and mortgage is in just my name. Do I have options?"
A: A real estate attorney will need to see how the title on the deed is held. Being 50% owner is not enough for a court to intervene with legal instructions as to how a property may or may not be partitioned. Real estate law is steeped in centuries of legal history – deeds contain “magic” legal language that has serious legal consequences. So have the deed reviewed by a real estate attorney who can tell you best how to proceed.
QUESTION NO. 2: "We sold our cottage on a land contract. The buyer is asking for a quitclaim deed so she can get help with repairs since she is now handicapped and habitat for humanity is saying she needs this in order for them to help her out. My concern is the loss of money owed to fulfill the contract?"
A: Until the buyer satisfies the terms of the land contract, they should NEVER be given a deed. That is the point of having a land contract. It works like an installment sales contract; only upon successful completion of all terms will the buyer satisfy the agreement and have a legal right to the deed. Until all instalments are paid, the buyer has not earned the right to property.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I was buying a house out of a probate and waited for months because the estate had to get permission to sell from the court. Three days before the closing date, the estate says they are now selling it to one of the sons. What are my rights?"
A: It will depend on what the purchase agreement between you and the seller says. Whenever you are dealing with such a large purchase, such as a home, and there are legal proceedings, probate or otherwise, it is best to have your own attorney represent your interest as the purchaser.
Week Of Jan 7, 2023
QUESTION NO. 1: "In disclosure the seller said a hot tub would not stay. We asked to keep in via the purchase agreement, they signed it. Who is right?"
A: A purchase agreement is a legally binding contract. Generally speaking, if the seller represents in the purchase agreement that an item will remain at the home after the sale, then they need to leave that item when they close on the home.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My former business partner removed me from the deed to a business property we owned together. My name is signed on the deed, and the signature is notarized, but on the date in question, I can prove that I was out of the country. What can I do?"
A: You should challenge the deed for fraud and have your signature verified by a handwriting expert. If the notary does not recant, and if your former business partner refuses to correct the problem then you will have to challenge the validity of the deed with a lawsuit.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I purchased a home with a pool in the winter. It was covered at the time of the home inspection. Once spring came, we removed the cover, it revealed that the pool was in terrible working order. The sellers deny responsibility. What are our rights?"
A: First, your sellers should have completed a separate disclosure form for the pool. These are necessary especially when the purchase transaction occurs in the winter, where it is virtually impossible to inspect a pool’s overall condition. If one was not completed, but still the seller failed to reveal the pool’s true condition, they still may be held accountable for intentional misrepresentation and in certain circumstances, you may be able to rescind the entire transaction even after the closing.
Week Of Dec 17, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "Can a township building inspector enforce more stringent building code requirements that exceed the state's building code? I am rehabilitating a historic barn as a residential home. There are some challenges because of the age and location of the barn and I have been told to get a structural engineering report before I proceed further."
A: Generally, the municipal building codes will set the forth minimum construction standards required to complete a building project. Your property sounds unique and therefore, it creates concerns for the building inspector. They can request an engineering report in order to issue your permit.
Click Here For More Information On This Topic |
QUESTION NO. 2: "I want to sell my home without my wife’s signature. The home was purchased during the marriage, but the title and loan are in my name only. Do I need her signature?"
A: In 2017, Michigan ended what you describe as “dower rights”. A spouse’s signature is no longer required to convey property. However, this does not mean that the title insurance company won’t still require her consent in order to convey marketable title.
QUESTION NO. 3: "We are in a contract to purchase a bank-owned auction property. We had to put down a 5% buyer premium on the house. The house appraised for $10,000 under our winning bid. If the bank is not willing to let the property go for the appraised price and we have to walk away, are we able to get our 5% buyer's premium back?"
A: When dealing with a private property auction company be prepared to engage with a more involved sales contract. They are very often “boiler-plate” and favorable to the seller. From the facts as presented, the contract provisions will prevail. Usually, there is very little room for refunds. A competent real estate attorney should review your document further. It is also better to have an attorney draft or review the sales auction contract beforehand, and not after the fact.
Week Of Dec 10, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "I own some real estate with a friend. We are falling out. Can a property owner force the co-owner to sell the jointly held property in order to obtain their share of a property's value?"
A: Tenants in common can compel the sale of a co-owned property through a legal action called “partition”. In certain circumstances where ownership is held as joint tenancies, courts cannot compel co-owners to sell their property. This is why it is so important to have an attorney review the “magic legal language” when creating a deed so there are no far reaching legal consequences that one lives to regret at a later date.
Click Here For More Information On This Topic |
QUESTION NO. 2: "Our real estate agent is acting as our buyer’s agent and she disclosed our financial information to my brother-in-law. Is this legal?"
A: Well, it would be quite unprofessional and unnecessary if your brother-in-law has no relation to the contemplated purchase transaction. You may want to contact the agent’s broker or the State of Michigan (LARA) to register a complaint. With regards to bringing a legal action, you would have to show how you were financially damaged.
QUESTION NO. 3: "When will a second addendum to a purchase agreement supersede the terms of a first addendum? The real estate agent wants to enforce terms to our agreement that we thought were removed by our second addendum?"
A: A purchase agreement can have multiple addendums. With each new addendum, the provisions found in the earlier purchase agreement and / or addendum will remain enforceable unless they are specifically revoked.
Week Of Nov 12, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "In my divorce judgment, I was given exclusive rights to a rental property of ours. My ex-wife is refusing to sign the refinance paperwork, removing herself, and initiated an eviction of my renter at the property. What should I do?"
A: The lender should recognize the judgment giving you the exclusive rights to the property, provided that the court order for divorce that awarded you the property was recorded with the registrar of deeds.
Click Here For More Information On This Topic |
QUESTION NO. 2: "What is the difference between a mortgage broker and a mortgage lender?"
A: Mortgage lenders and banks control the entire financing process, while mortgage brokers are ‘money-finders’ and typically do not control the underwriting process or funding of a mortgage. In my experience, while brokers are better able to shop your loan request around to different lenders to get the best rate and terms for their clients, lenders can make quicker and more flexible loan decisions.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I'm buying a home. The seller's trustee had a life estate and was allowed to sell the property during their lifetime. They died soon after they signed the purchase contract. Does this bind the trust beneficiaries?"
A: The provisions of the trust should control. Regardless of their recent passing, if the seller had the authority to sell the property during their lifetime, then the other beneficiaries of the trust are also bound by that provision. This is provided however, that your sales agreement was signed by all parties and there were no further contingencies to close your transaction.
Week Of Nov 4, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "If I am the seller on a land contract, how is my interest protected if there is a fire or other damage to the home? Do I need to get hazard insurance or does the buyer? How does this work?"
A: Your buyer has an insurable, equitable interest in the property. The buyer needs to have a hazard insurance policy on the home for the purchase price — at a minimum. They then named YOU as the LOSS PAYEE on the insurance policy. If there is a fire or any other damage, your balance gets paid off first. You are the legal owner. The buyer gets the difference between what they owe you and what they insure the property for. That’s how it works.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My seller's partner needs to sign papers to close the home. He is not lucid. Their realtor said she would get him to sign a power of attorney to his son. Is this right or even legal?"
A: If the seller is not competent to sign closing documents, he certainly cannot make his son his power of attorney at this point. Instead, the family needs to file for a conservatorship and have the court appoint the son as a conservator. A conservator is legally authorized to manage an incapacitated person’s financial affairs. This would include the sale or mortgage of a home. While this may delay the closing, doing anything less than this may open the transaction up to legal challenges later.
QUESTION NO. 3: "The contractor I hired is ignoring my calls to do the agreed upon work? What are my rights against a company who took but did not earn my money, according to a contract?"
A: If your contractor has failed to provide the services that you hired them to perform, then you have a breach of contract claim. If you are not having success with resolving the matter on your own, then seek out the advice of legal counsel — often, a little legal pressure can go a long way.
Week Of October 29, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "I purchased a mixed-use property. I have several tenants that are leasing from me, but these were leases in effect at the time that I purchased the building. If the lease agreement is for three years after that period, can I raise their rent amount?"
A: It will depend on what the lease provisions in the contract says. If the tenant has an option to renew for a specific amount already stated in the lease, then you may not be able to raise the rent. If there is no provision addressing an option to renew, then you can.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I am going to act as the banker for family members in order to buy property. How do I go about creating the necessary documents?"
A: It sounds as if you wish to provide private financing. You most likely are going to need to create a land contract between you and your family or create a private mortgage. Either selection has its pros and cons. You should consult with a competent real estate attorney to address your concerns further.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a seller's realtor sue me if I cancel the purchase agreement and back out of a closing that did not occur by the date listed in the purchase agreement?"
A: Generally “no,” the seller’s agent has no rights against you directly for commission or any other fees. Their agreement is between the seller only. However, a buyer’s agent can bring an action against you for their portion of the commission that the buyer’s agent would have earned had you closed. The seller may have an equitable action against you (depends on the remedies set forth in the purchase agreement) for specific performance and can compel a sale.
Week Of October 22, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "Can I sue a home inspector who had falsely reported roof conditions?"
A: Normally, home inspectors limit their liability to the amount of the price of their inspection report. They state this in their contract with the prospective homeowner. However, they are not protected from gross negligence. It is important for you to have an attorney review the home inspection report further. The extent of damages would be based upon the disclosed lifetime of the roof at the time of your purchase.
QUESTION NO. 2: "Can a mortgage company pursue me on the mortgage even after I filed bankruptcy years ago?"
A: Even though your personal liability under the promissory note has been discharged, the terms of the mortgage remain in effect and the owner of the mortgage can still have a lien on the real estate. After the bankruptcy, the lender can ask for a new payment plan from the borrower or they can foreclosure on the property. They just can’t pursue you personally.
QUESTION NO. 3: "How do I make sure that a buyer cannot back out a few days before closing on my home? Can you suggest some language to add in the contract?"
A: Valid purchase agreements are contracts and are legally enforceable. The provisions of any contract spell out the legal remedies that parties to a contract have against each other in the event one party defaults. In your instance, there should be language in the contract that addresses the buyer’s performance contingencies. Once a certain time has passed in a purchase agreement, performance contingencies need to be waived by the buyer. With the contingency having been satisfied, if the buyer defaults thereafter and does not close the transaction, the seller can then enforce their legal remedies, which will vary by contract.
Week Of October 14, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "My father passed away and I am the personal representative. He left a will but the home is not listed. Can I still sell the home because I am the personal representative?"
A: Being named as a personal representative in a will is not enough. You must have the Probate Court’s permission to sell the home. You cannot just sell a home that is not listed as part of the estate until you list the home as an asset of the estate.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I have real estate documents that prove I own a home, but my significant other wants to sell it without me? Can my partner sell a property that I have an interest in without me?"
A: Provided that your real estate documents are actually conveyance documents recognized by statute, and recorded, then the answer is ‘no’, your partner cannot sell the home without you.
QUESTION NO. 3: "What is a Land Contract?"
A: A land contract is an instalment sales agreement for real estate. The seller (vendor) sells the property to the buyer (vendee), but the legal title (the deed) remains with the seller until the buyer complies with the provisions of the contract and the purchase price is completely paid off. A land contract is more or less a form of seller financing. A purchase agreement is needed to establish the terms for the land contract.
Week Of October 7, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "How long after a home inspection is complete do the potential buyers have to agree to move forward with a purchase agreement?"
A: That will all depend on the terms of the purchase agreement. Typically the buyer has 7 days from the date of the signed purchase agreement to perform an inspection (hire your own inspector – not one referred by your sales person). If there is a problem or concern raised by the home inspector, you usually will have 2 -3 days from the date you receive the home inspection report, to inform the Seller. These time frames can be negotiated.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I have a Power of Attorney for my wife. Do I have to be a co-signer on her separate bank account in order to access the bank account on her behalf?"
A: No. You do not have to be a co-signer on a person’s bank account provided that you have a valid Power of Attorney that gives you that authority. Just present that document to the bank official and they should accommodate you and your wife.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I agreed to purchase a building in "as is" condition. The property suffered extensive damage during the escrow period. Can I still collect the insurance proceeds paid to the Seller for extensive property damage?"
A: That will depend upon what you and your seller agreed to in the purchase agreement. If your understanding was that insurance proceeds would be disbursed to you, and it is not reduced to writing, then it is most likely that you lost the right to assert a claim for the proceeds. Our contracts have provisions that address the proper amount of insurance funds that can be allocated to either party in the event there is a problem with the property while under contract.
Week Of October 1, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "My son is having a hard time getting rid of everything in the home that he inherited in time for the closing. What can the new owners legally do to my son if we are unable to get rid of the contents in the home?"
A: Generally, purchase agreements have provisions that require that a home be vacated by the seller before a closing. That would include the seller’s personal property. Buyers should perform a “final walk through” of a home before a closing to ensure that the home is in the same condition that it was at the time of the purchase offer, and that repairs, if any, have been completed. Buyers do not have to close on a property if the overall condition of the home is not acceptable. If your son is having a difficult time paying for the removal of the home contents, the parties could also agree to hold money back from the seller’s proceeds to pay for the removal of personal property.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My tenant's daughter has epilepsy/autism. Her doctor prescribed her a service dog. My lease does not allow pets but according to the tenant, this dog is a psychiatric service dog, not just a pet. Can I legally say 'No' to my tenant?"
A: No. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, landlords and housing facilities must allow service dogs and emotional support animals, if necessary for a person with a disability to have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy the home. To fall under this provision, a person must have a disability and must have a disability-related need for the animal. In other words, the animal must work, perform tasks or services, or alleviate the emotional effects of your disability in order to qualify. A doctor’s prescription is sufficient evidence of the disability.
QUESTION NO. 3: "Can a purchaser legally sell or rent a house on land contract if there is a mortgage?"
A: Once a purchaser comes into legal title to a property, they can sell a property on land contract. They will need to have a real estate attorney review the underlying mortgage to see if the “due on sale” provision of the mortgage will pose a problem or not.
Week Of September 24, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "I have to get an apartment before closing. Can you suggest some language to add in the contract?"
A: Valid purchase agreements are contracts and are legally enforceable. The provisions of any contract spell out the legal remedies that parties to a contract have against each other in the event one party defaults. In your instance, there should be language in the contract that addresses the buyer’s performance contingencies. Once a certain time period has passed in a purchase agreement, performance contingencies need to be waived by the buyer. With the contingency having been satisfied, if the buyer defaults thereafter and does not close the transaction, the seller can then enforce their legal remedies, which will vary by contract.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My apartment complex removed everyone's balconies mid-lease. They claim that the city made them do it. What can we do?"
A: While it sounds as if the complex was removing the balconies in compliance with the city’s building enforcement, there is no harm in requesting a reduction in rent because the balcony was part of the space initially leased. You may have the ability to exit the lease without penalty, however, the lease provisions should be reviewed. A way to calculate the rent reduction is based upon the square footage of the balcony.
QUESTION NO. 3: "When a property is in foreclosure, does a tenant have to pay rent? If so, to who?"
A: Until the interest of the homeowner is completely extinguished, the lease obligation remains. But practically speaking, when tenants find out that their landlord is in foreclosure..they don’t pay.
Week Of September 19, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "Could knowledge of a lawsuit be considered "actual service" of the lawsuit?"
A: No, one must be personally served by a process server to be properly served, however, if, for some reason, you cannot be served personally, then the plaintiff can serve you through a court ordered publication in the legal news, regular mail or even a posting on the property. In the case of property tax forfeiture, posting and publication can be considered adequate notice.
QUESTION NO. 2: "My tenant's daughter has epilepsy/ autism. Her doctor prescribed her a service dog. My lease does not allow pets but according to the tenant, this dog is a psychiatric dog not just a pet. Can I legally say "No" to my tenant?"
A: No. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, landlords and housing facilities must allow service dogs and emotional support animals, if necessary, for a person with a disability to have an equal opportunity to use and enjoy the home. To fall under this provision, a person must have a disability and must have a disability-related need for the animal. In other words, the animal must work, perform tasks or services, or alleviate the emotional effects of your disability in order to qualify. A doctor’s prescription is sufficient evidence of the disability.
QUESTION NO. 3: "I have a former business partner trying to sue me on an old promissory note that I haven't paid on in over 12 years. How can he sue me now? So much time has passed?"
A: Generally speaking, the time frame to collect on a promissory note is no greater than 6 years from the last date of payment. Known as a “statute of limitations,” if your old partner has failed to bring an action within the 6 years, their claim may be barred.
Week Of September 12, 2022
QUESTION NO. 1: "My brother refuses to turn over my mother's original will to prevent my other siblings and I from probating her estate. Can he do that? What do I do?"
A: No, he cannot legally do that. Michigan probate judges have the authority to compel your brother to produce the original will if it does exist. Among other things, he can be held in contempt of court.
There are also alternatives to have the estate probated even without your brother’s cooperation. It just makes for an even longer legal process.
QUESTION NO. 2: "I received a deed titled "Warranty Deed", but when I went to secure title insurance for my property, the title agent refused coverage because he says the deed is really a quit claim deed. What can I do now?"
A: A warranty deed is the best type of conveyance deed a buyer or grantee can receive from a seller. It contains 6 implied legal promises; among the most important warranty is the grantor’s guarantee to defend the grantee against all third party claims to the property.
A Quit Claim deed doesn’t contain any warranties. It is basically a document that conveys any interest that the grantor MAY have in the property; which could be no property rights at all. That is why the title insurance agent will not insure over a quit claim deed.
It does not matter how a deed is titled. The substance of the legal language contained within the deed controls.
QUESTION NO. 3: "A distant family member became a care giver to my sick father moving into the home to provide care two months before his death. After he passed away she filed a deed to this home naming her as the grantee. But in In his earlier will he had left his home to me. This is so sudden. What can I do?"
If you suspect that your relative “overreached,” then you have the right to challenge this late and surprising conveyance. There is a “rebuttable presumption” of undue influence when a “substantial beneficiary” of a proposed will had a “confidential relationship” with the decedent and used that relationship to “actively procure” the will or in this case, the deed. In simple terms, if someone abused their trust to manipulate your father into leaving them the bulk of their estate, a judge will assume there was undue influence unless this family member can prove otherwise. So, the only way to challenge your relative is to bring an action against them in court.
.
If You Like These Questions, then Join Us For “Office Hours”
at 4:00-5:00 P.M. EST on the 2nd and 4th Friday of each month for an open ended live Q&A session with Attorney David Soble and his associates.
The time is set aside for YOU to ask YOUR legal questions, so Ask Away!